Investigation: Merritt Island Georgiana Cemetery

Source 1 · web_page · link_only

Many Believe This Eerie 200-Year-Old Graveyard In Florida Is Haunted

https://familydestinationsguide.com/eerie-historical-graveyard-florida/

Publication/archive: Family Destinations Archive

Date: April 17, 2024

The article highlights Georgiana Cemetery, a centuries-old, lesser-known historic site located in Merritt Island, Florida.

Here are the key takeaways from the piece:

Atmosphere & History: Established in the early 19th century, the cemetery is described as having a "Southern Gothic" charm, featuring moss-draped oak trees and headstones dating back to the 1800s. It is portrayed as a quiet, reflective place that feels separated from the modern world.

Haunted Reputation: While some locals share legends of the site being haunted, the author notes that visitors primarily experience a peaceful environment. However, some visitors do report "extrasensory" phenomena, such as mysterious orbs in photographs or hushed voices.

Visitor Tips: The author encourages visitors to approach the site with respect, as it is a sacred space. They recommend visiting during daylight hours and taking time to sit and reflect on the history of the early settlers and war veterans interred there.

Location: The cemetery is located at 3970 Crooked Mile Rd, Merritt Island, FL 32952.

Source 2 · web_page · link_only

Georgiana Cemetery

https://www.atlasobscura.com/places/georgiana-cemetery

Publication/archive: Atlas Obscura

Date: March 13, 2019

Georgiana Cemetery, also known as Crooked Mile Cemetery, is one of the oldest graveyards in Brevard County, Florida. It is quaint and beautiful, with many tall trees adorned with Spanish moss, which blows eerily in the wind coming in off the water.

While interesting because of its age, history, and beauty, the Georgiana Cemetery may be best known as the burial place of a local murder victim and supposed ghost, Ethel Allen. Allen was just 19 years old when she was found murdered and mutilated on the banks of the Indian River Lagoon in the early 1900s. Nearly a century later, her murder is still unsolved, though there was a potential suspect who was never found.

Perhaps due to the grisly circumstances surrounding Allen's death, and the general eerie atmosphere of the old cemetery, there have been many reports of ghost sightings and the feeling of spirits in the area. Some believe that Allen's ghost haunts the cemetery where she is interred. Adding to the curiosity, the headstone of Allen's grave is handmade, making it unique among the other graves in the cemetery. To this day, her gravesite is regularly decorated by unknown benefactors.

Source 3 · web_page · link_only

Georgiana Cemetery

https://hauntbound.com/locations/fl/georgiana-cemetery-merritt-island/

Publication/archive: Haunt Bound

Date: May 2026

The paranormal reputation of Georgiana Cemetery centers chiefly on Ethel Allen, the young murder victim whose killer was never found. Because her death was so violent and her case was never resolved, local tradition holds that her spirit remains bound to the cemetery where she was buried. Multiple visitors and paranormal investigators have reported seeing apparitions on the cemetery grounds, hearing disembodied voices, and capturing electronic voice phenomena (EVP) during after-dark investigations, though the cemetery closes at dusk.

Space Coast Daily has listed Georgiana Cemetery among the most haunted places in Brevard County, citing visitor reports of unusual photographic anomalies and the feeling of being watched near the older portions of the grounds. The handmade nature of Ethel Allen's headstone makes her grave easy to locate and frequently visited by those drawn to the site.

The adjacent Georgianna United Methodist Church, dating to 1886, adds to the historic atmosphere of the location. Local lore collected by regional researchers also describes sensations of being physically touched while walking among the older grave sections, and unexplained lights appearing near the tree line at the edge of the cemetery.

Source 4 · web_page · link_only

7. Georgiana Graveyard, Merritt Island

https://www.discovertitusville.com/ghost-stories/7-georgiana-graveyard-merritt-island

Publication/archive: Discover Titusville

Date: 05/16/2024

Though the settlement is no more, evidence of it can still be found in the form of the old cemetery that still stands. Georgiana Graveyard is known to be haunted, and it draws ghost lovers from all over, who come in search of paranormal experiences, including apparitions, voices and shining balls of light that have been encountered here.

The most infamous of its many phantoms, however, is the tragic spirit of Ethel Allen. Ethel was the victim of a murder in November 17th, 1934. Her desecrated body was found in the Indian River Lagoon, and her assailant has never been found to this day.

She was just 19 years old when she was interred at Merritt Island, and many say she’s walked these grounds ever since.